Artistic Echoes: The Struggles of Realism vs. the Serenity of Post-Impressionism - Movements following the Romantic Era

Artistic Echoes: The Struggles of Realism vs. the Serenity of Post-Impressionism - Movements Following the Romantic Era

The Romantic Era, characterised by emotional depth and a break from traditional artistic conventions, birthed two standout movements that have significantly impacted the art world: Realism and Post-Impressionism. Each of these styles has unique characteristics shaped by its respective historical contexts, yet they diverge dramatically in their approaches to subject matter and artistic expression. This blog will delve into four pivotal works—two from each movement—assessing their artistic elements, intentions, and emotional resonance, ultimately articulating my preference for Post-Impressionism over Realism.

Historical Context: The Stage for Artistic Transformation

    The backdrop for Realism and Post-Impressionism is rich with social and political upheaval. Realism arose during the 1840s when France experienced turmoil with revolutions and the rise of the bourgeoisie. Following the aftermath of Napoleon’s reign, there was a resurgence of class struggles, and artists sought to depict the lives of ordinary people, often focusing on the working class, to expose the harsh realities they faced. The Industrial Revolution significantly contributed to these changes, transforming raw materials and labour through new technologies like the steam engine and gas lighting, leading to increased urbanisation and concentrated working classes near transportation hubs.

    Post-Impressionism, on the other hand, emerged towards the end of the 19th century, marking a rejection of the fleeting representations characteristic of Impressionism. Artists in this movement sought a more personal, emotional, and abstract approach to their subjects, emphasising memories and feelings over mere visual representation. This rejection of superficiality in Post-Impressionism allows for a deeper exploration of the emotional and psychological aspects of the artwork.

Realism: Art as Social Commentary

Realism aimed to depict "real life" and the everyday experiences of people, particularly those marginalised by society. Artists within this movement adopted an unembellished style, often utilising dark, earthy palettes and rejecting traditional pictorial techniques to bring attention to life's usually uncomfortable truths. Their intentions were guided by a desire to provoke thought, stimulate social change, and redefine what constituted acceptable subject matter for fine art.

A Burial at Ornans by Gustave Courbet (1851, Paris, France) 

A Burial at Ornans: Gustave Courbet

  

  

     Courbet's A Burial at Ornans fully demonstrates the sombre reality of rural life. The painting depicts a funeral in the small town of Ornans, with a crowd gathered around the grave without any sense of spiritual elevation. The dark colour palette, dominated by shades of browns and blacks, creates a weighty atmosphere that underscores the gravity of death. The figures, presented in a rough, everyday manner, eschew idealisation and instead embrace an unflinching portrayal of grief.

    The composition is marked by a solid horizontal line, emphasising the community's collective mourning rather than focusing on the individual. The emotional tension is palpable in the varied expressions of the figures—some mourn dutifully, while others appear more detached, hinting at a broader societal commentary. Courbet's intention was radical; he aimed to democratise art by placing the commoner as its subject, which at the time was a departure from the grand historical or mythical themes favoured by traditional academies (Caesura Magazine). He wanted viewers, particularly the bourgeoisie, to confront the brutal truths of life and death, fostering an engagement that would lead to social awareness and change.

    I believe A Burial at Ornans encapsulates a profound emotional resonance transcending its immediate subject matter. The rawness of the scene, with its sombre colours and the unvarnished portrayal of grief, strikes a chord that is both unsettling and deeply moving. Courbet's deliberate choice to depict ordinary townsfolk in a moment of communal mourning brought humanity to death, which had often been idealised or romanticised in art. The stark presentation, marked by strong horizontal lines and a lack of defined focal points, emphasises the collective experience of loss, inviting viewers to confront their feelings about mortality. Furthermore, considering the historical context of the painting—created during a period of significant social upheaval and the rise of the working class—we can appreciate how Courbet's work challenges the elitist norms of art at the time. Instead of portraying grand historical events or classical mythology, he draws attention to the people's everyday lives, making a poignant statement about their realities. This artistic decision reflects the tumultuous social climate of 19th-century France and resonates with contemporary audiences, reminding us that in grief, there is a shared human experience that transcends time.

The Gleaners by Jean-François Millet (1857, Paris, France) 

The Gleaners: Musee Orsay

   Millet’s The Gleaners captures a poignant slice of rural life, depicting women gleaning the leftover grains after a harvest. The painting employs a warm, earthy colour palette and strong diagonal lines that lead the viewer’s eyes across the scene. The use of light, especially the warm glow of the setting sun, casts a sculptural quality over the gleaners, emphasising their form and labour.

    The women are portrayed with dignity despite the drudgery of their task, speaking to their resilience. However, the man's figure on horseback in the background is a sharp reminder of class dynamics, reinforcing the ruling class structures that govern labour. Millet also sought to elevate the status of peasant life, portraying the beautiful simplicity of their labour and dignity amid adversity. This subtle social commentary encourages viewers to reflect on their social structures and the lives of those often overlooked. While I can appreciate Millet’s intention to highlight the plight of the rural poor, I find the overall composition too subdued. The focus on simplicity and the starkness of their labour fails to evoke the emotional depth I seek in art. While admirable for its genuine reflection of life, the work's simplicity leaves me yearning for a deeper aesthetic engagement (Musée d'Orsay).

Post-Impressionism: A Journey into Emotion

In stark contrast, Post-Impressionism sought to convey the artist's emotional landscape, using vivid colours and abstract forms to explore the world subjectively rather than merely representationally. This movement is characterised by embracing symbolism, personal expression, and pursuing new artistic ideas. Post-Impressionist artists aimed to communicate deeper emotional truths and invite viewers to engage with their feelings and interpretations of the artwork.

Muse by Henri Martin (1900, France) 

Muse: Henri Martin

 

    In Muse, Martin combines pointillist techniques with soft pastel colours, creating a scene that transcends reality to evoke emotion. The soft brushstrokes transform the character into a serene figure surrounded by blossoms and sunlight. The way the colours merge and mingle invites the viewer to step back and appreciate the composition without getting lost in minute details. From a distance, the figure emerges more clearly, while up close, the piece becomes an intricate tapestry of dots and patterns.

 Martin sought to convey beauty and emotional resonance, emphasising the connection between the viewer and the experience depicted. I find the tranquillity and beauty in this artwork captivating. The pastel colours and light evoke nostalgia and calmness, cocooning me in warmth. Martin’s use of light on the muse’s white dress and the surrounding flora resonates with a dreamlike quality that lifts the spirit and embodies the essence of beauty. He intended to immerse the viewer in a moment of serenity and reflection, which aligns with my preference for art that engages the senses and stirs something deeper within the viewer.

Choosing a Book by Édouard Vuillard (1896, France)

Choosing a Book: Edouard Vuillard

 

    Vuillard's Choosing a Book depicts an intimate domestic scene, bursting with colour patterns and textures. The figure of a woman amidst a vibrant array of reds, pinks, and yellows draws the viewer into her world as she searches for a book. Decorative patterns evoke a sense of closeness and familiarity, and the dynamic interplay of colour and texture creates an engaging atmosphere. The detailed carpet and floral motifs surrounding the woman contribute to the overall sense of intimacy.

 Vuillard intended to capture a moment in daily life and a deep emotional experience—a sense of comfort and joy in simple activities. I particularly resonate with this piece because it reflects moments of solitude and contemplation—feelings I often indulge in when exploring a bookstore. The rich palette creates a cosy feeling that envelops the viewer, drawing them into the scene’s warm embrace. Vuillard’s ability to marry domesticity with emotional depth reflects a desire for connection to the everyday experience in a meaningful way. The intricate patterns remind me of the joys found in the mundane, elevating a simple act of choosing a book into a moment of personal significance.

Aesthetic Reaction and Personal Preference

     When comparing Realism and Post-Impressionism, I favour the latter for its ability to explore the complexities of human emotions. While Realism serves a vital role in social critique, presenting an unvarnished view of society, I often feel a distance from the subjects depicted—an emotional disconnect that comes from the heavy focus on suffering and the struggle for survival. In contrast, Post-Impressionism allows for a rich personal connection; it invites viewers to engage with emotion and beauty rather than just mundane existence.

  For me, art is more than a commentary on society; it is a personal experience that allows for emotional resonance and aesthetic pleasure. I find immense value in the beauty facilitated by colour, light, and abstraction used by Post-Impressionists. These works leave me feeling uplifted and transported into a world that values emotion, colour, and a sense of deep connection with the subjects portrayed.

    The discussion of Realism and Post-Impressionism reveals distinct artistic philosophies shaped by their historical contexts. Realism's commitment to portraying life's uncomfortable truths reflects the significant social changes of its time, yet often prioritises substance over aesthetic appeal. Conversely, Post-Impressionism emerges as a movement transcending the mundane, encouraging deeper emotional engagement through colour, abstraction, and symbolism. For my artistic preferences, the emotional depth, beauty, and intricately personal narratives presented in Post-Impressionism resonate more profoundly than the often stark realities depicted in Realism.

---

Works Cited

-Caesura Magazine. “The Magnitude of a Young Courbet: Reflections on A Burial at Ornans.” Caesura Magazine. https://caesuramag.org/posts/the-magnitude-of-a-young-courbet-reflections-on-a-burial-at-ornans. 

-Musée d'Orsay. “The Gleaners.” Musée d'Orsay. https://www.musee-orsay.fr/en/artworks/des-glaneuses-342.

-Pissarro Art. “Muse.” Pissarro Art.

https://www.pissarro.art/artworksdetails/872046/17400/henri-martin-1860-1943-muse.

-Painting Mania. “Figures in an Interior: Choosing a Book.” Painting Mania. https://www.paintingmania.com/figures-interior-choosing-book-200_24437.html.